2012 NFL Fantasy Football: Who's Number 1?
Athlon Sports debates who should be taken with the first pick in a fantasy football draft
By: Athlon Sports | 6/26/12, 6:00 AM EDT
You have the first pick in your fantasy football draft. Who are you taking? Athlon Sports has Houston Texan running back Arian Foster No. 1 overall in its rankings and on its Big Board, but that doesn't necessarily mean it was an unanimous decision.
Six different Athlon editors and one fantasy football contributor were asked who they would take with the first pick. Foster was the clear-cut choice with four votes, but two other running backs and a certain reigning NFL MVP and cover boy quarterback received one vote each as well. Below are the cases made for each player.
Arian Foster for No. 1
“This guy averaged 3.5 more points per game than anyone else at his position in 2010. He led all running backs in scoring average again in 2011 despite opening the year with a bad hamstring. You don’t need to make a case for him. You need to search for reasons to pick anyone else. So what are they? Ray Rice catches more passes? He didn’t in 2010, when both played a full season. Aaron Rodgers? He was stellar last year... and yet only one point per game better than Drew Brees. LeSean McCoy? His coach says McCoy needs to touch the ball less this year than he did last year. Ben Tate? He didn’t hurt Foster in 2011. The only thing to dislike about Foster is the loss of his right tackle, Eric Winston. Frankly, this back has earned the benefit of the doubt.” — Matt Schauf, DraftSharks.com
“I have always scoffed at those who say you cannot take a QB in the first round. Well, we will see how much that changes this year when Aaron Rodgers is a top three or four pick. We had him at No. 6 overall last year, and he paid off for us. With that said, the question is: Who’s No. 1 in 2012? Arian Foster still gets my nod. He was a non-factor in four games and still had over 300 points for the season. I’m also a schedule nerd, and Foster has seven games against rushing defenses ranked 17th or worst last season, including five of the last six weeks.” — Corby Yarbrough, Athlon Sports (@Corby_Yarborough)
Aaron Rodgers for No. 1
“Last year was a tough call — I voted for Adrian Peterson — but this year is even more difficult. I love LeSean McCoy’s situation in Philadelphia, but can he hold up for 350 touches for a third season? I love Ray Rice’s and Arian Foster’s feature-back status. But in the modern era of running back by committee — which is beginning to have an increasingly volatile relief pitcher feel to it of late — I would have to lean towards the safest player in the NFL, Green Bay quarterback Aaron Rodgers. The league averages at the quarterback position have reached all-time highs, and passing for 4,000 yards and 25 touchdowns is almost a low-water mark for success at the position. With the depth at running back and wide receiver this year, my advice is to target an elite passer early and build around him. You can’t win your fantasy league with the first pick, but you can certainly lose it. Rodgers is the closest to a sure thing in the 2012 draft room.” — Braden Gall, Athlon Sports (@BradenGall)
Ray Rice for No. 1
“My choice for the No. 1 overall fantasy selection is Ravens running back Ray Rice. The dynamic Rice was the only player in the NFL to gain over 2,000 yards from scrimmage last year, the second time he has accomplished that feat in the last three seasons. The concern of other Baltimore backs stealing scoring opportunities was alleviated in 2011, with Rice tallying 15 total touchdowns. Other runners like Arian Foster of the Texans or LeSean McCoy of the Eagles are solid choices as well, but Rice’s consistent running and pass-catching make him the best option at the top of the draft. Additionally, I don’t mind taking a top quarterback like Green Bay’s Aaron Rodgers or New Orleans’ Drew Brees in the first round, but getting a top running back in the first three or four overall picks will tend to be the better decision for your fantasy squad.” — Patrick Snow, Athlon Sports (@AthlonSnowman)
Chris Johnson for No. 1
“Rumors of Chris Johnson’s demise have been greatly exaggerated. The 26-year-old is in his prime, has never missed a game due to injury and has a better single season in the books (remember CJ2K?) than any of his peers. Johnson’s per-season average is 1,768 yards from scrimmage and 11 total TDs; take away the record-breaking 2,509-yard, 16-TD 2009 season, and he still averages 1,521 yards from scrimmage and nine total TDs. Obviously, CJ disappointed fantasy owners last season. Following an NFL lockout and contract holdout, Johnson struggled to find his stride with a new coach, play-caller and quarterback in Tennessee. But it was business as usual over the last eight games, when he piled up 893 of his 1,465 yards from scrimmage and three of his four total TDs. Entering his second year with the Titans’ new regime and coming off his worst season as a pro, the fastest man in the NFL should be the No. 1 fantasy pick.” — Nathan Rush, Athlon Sports
— Published on June 26, 2012
Athlon Sports 2012 NFL Fantasy Content:
Athlon Sports Big Board: Top 150
2012 NFL Fantasy Football Athlon's Top 250
2012 Fantasy Football Mock Draft I
2012 Bye Week Cheat Sheet
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: QBs
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: RBs
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: WRs
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: TEs
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: DLs
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: LBs
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: DBs
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: IDP Top 75
Most Popular Articles
Sign Up For Our Newsletter
Get the latest news and find out what our Athlon Sports experts have to say each week.
Contests & Promotions
Athlon Sports Fantasy Racing!
Enter the Athlon Sports Fantasy Racing game. Just head over to athlon.myfantasyracing.com and register for your chance to win a chance to watch a 2014 race from the grandstands. You'll also have a chance to win other amazing prizes such as an autographed Kyle Busch helmet.